What a substitute is
- A substitute is any chemical used as a refrigerant to replace a CFC, HCFC or other ozone-depleting substance.
- EPA's examples: HFCs, PFCs, HFOs (hydrofluoroolefins), HFEs, hydrocarbons, ammonia, carbon dioxide and blends of these.
- R-22 is not a substitute; it is itself a class II (HCFC) substance.
- Most substitutes are covered by the venting ban, the sales restriction and the recovery rules. Only a short list of "exempt" uses, such as carbon dioxide, nitrogen and water, is outside them.
No drop-ins: retrofits and oils
EPA's Core list stresses that there is no true drop-in replacement. Moving a system to a different refrigerant is a retrofit.
- A retrofit can mean changing the oil, gaskets, filters, driers, valves, o-rings or other parts so everything is compatible with the new refrigerant.
- Many substitutes do not mix well with the oils used with CFCs and HCFCs, and the older refrigerants do not mix well with many new oils.
- EPA's pairing to remember: ester oils with R-134a (an HFC); alkylbenzene oils with HCFCs such as R-22.
- Never top up a system with a different refrigerant to "make it work"; EPA's Core list says to avoid mixing refrigerants.
Blends and fractionation
- Many substitutes are blends of two or more refrigerants.
- Fractionation is when the parts of a blend leak out at different rates. After a leak, the mix left in the system may no longer match the original.
- That is one more reason to find and fix leaks rather than keep adding refrigerant.
The HFC phasedown (AIM Act)
HFCs do not harm ozone, but many have high global warming potentials. The AIM Act of 27 December 2020 gives EPA power to cut their use.
- U.S. HFC production and consumption must fall 85 percent from historic baselines by 2036, through yearly allowances. The first step was a 10 percent cut in 2022.
- Worldwide, the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol aims for an 80 to 85 percent HFC cut by 2047. The U.S. ratified it in October 2022.
- Since 1 January 2026, 40 CFR Part 84 leak repair rules apply to appliances with 15 pounds or more of an HFC or a substitute with a GWP above 53. Residential and light commercial AC is excluded.
- Since 1 January 2026, refrigerant sold as "reclaimed" may contain at most 15 percent virgin HFC by weight, and reclaimers must label containers to say so.
- From 1 January 2029, servicing HFC equipment in supermarkets, refrigerated transport and automatic commercial ice makers must use reclaimed refrigerant.
Common traps
- R-410A is not a drop-in for R-22; there is no drop-in at all.
- EPA pairs esters with R-134a and alkylbenzenes with HCFCs; do not swap them.
- The AIM Act is a phasedown to 15 percent of baseline, not a full ban on HFCs.
- The 15 percent in the reclaim rule is a virgin-content cap; 15 pounds is the leak-repair size threshold. Do not mix them up.
Key terms
- Substitute
- A refrigerant used in place of a CFC or HCFC, such as an HFC, HFO, hydrocarbon, ammonia or CO2.
- Drop-in
- A replacement that needs no system changes; EPA says there are none.
- Retrofit
- Converting an appliance to a different refrigerant, often with new oil and seals.
- Ester oil
- Lubricant EPA pairs with the HFC R-134a.
- Alkylbenzene
- Lubricant EPA pairs with HCFCs such as R-22.
- Fractionation
- Parts of a refrigerant blend leaking at different rates, changing the mix left behind.
- AIM Act
- 2020 U.S. law that phases down HFCs and sets rules on leaks and reclaim.
- Kigali Amendment
- Addition to the Montreal Protocol that phases down HFCs worldwide.